Current:Home > MarketsHow much is $1,000 a month worth? New study explores impact of basic income -Aspire Financial Strategies
How much is $1,000 a month worth? New study explores impact of basic income
View
Date:2025-04-27 17:50:32
Millions of Americans struggle to afford basics like food and rent. A new study spearheaded by the CEO of ChatGPT’s parent company shows regular, unconditional cash payments could help.
A three-year study from OpenResearch, a nonprofit research organization backed by OpenAI CEO Sam Altman, examined the effects of a no-strings-attached $1,000-a-month cash transfer on recipients’ health, employment and spending. It’s the latest and largest study of its kind to show how unconditional cash could help lower-income families meet basic needs like food and housing.
“We’re all finding the same results,” said Stacia West, co-founder and director of the University of Pennsylvania’s Center for Guaranteed Income Research. “You give people cash, and they make great decisions for themselves and their family in a way that you know can promote upward economic mobility."
What are the effects of guaranteed basic income?
OpenResearch’s study kicked off in 2020 with 3,000 lower-income participants recruited through Illinois and Texas nonprofits. One thousand participants received $1,000 a month in cash to spend however they’d like, and a 2,000-person control group received $50 a month.
Learn more: Best current CD rates
Overall, researchers said, their findings suggest cash “provides flexibility.”
Study:Over two-thirds of Americans are stressed by everyday expenses – these are the most frustrating ones
"The data we collected highlights the complexity of people’s lives and needs," reads a statement from OpenResearch shared with USA TODAY. "Cash provides the flexibility to meet those diverse needs, and it is responsive when needs shift based on a person’s circumstances."
According to the study:
- Recipients increased their spending by $310 a month on average, primarily using the money for essentials like food, housing and transportation.
- The money was also used as financial support for others, with recipients spending an average of $22 more a month on things like gifts to friends and family, loans, donations to charity and alimony payments.
- Recipients worked 1.3 hours less a week on average compared with the control group and reported more leisure time but remained engaged in the workforce.
- Recipients were 26% more likely to visit a hospital in the last year of the study and 10% more likely to get dental care and visit an emergency room. They also reported a decrease in problematic alcohol and some types of illicit drug use.
- Recipients were 4.4 percentage points more likely to move neighborhoods. OpenResearch plans to look into how the cash transfers affected housing stability and neighborhood quality in future analyses.
- Recipients ‒ especially Black and female recipients ‒ were more likely to report having an idea for a business. Recipients also reported a greater likelihood of starting a business within the next five years.
But OpenResearch’s findings also indicate cash isn’t the solution for everything.
- There were no significant effects on physical health, self-reported access to health care or behaviors like exercise or sleep.
- The study found notable improvements in stress, mental distress and food security – but only during the first year of the study. Those effects faded by the second year. An OpenResearch spokesperson said macroeconomic factors ‒ like inflation and the loss of pandemic-era aid ‒ may have eroded the initial improvements, but researchers will continue to analyze the data.
Sevly Snguon, co-founder and co-chair of the Guaranteed Income Health Consortium at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, said various research shows guaranteed income is just one piece of the puzzle.
"There's still a need for additional resources for people who are parents. They might need more childcare, more support there. Affordable housing, health care," they said. "But guaranteed income helps with people during those key transition periods."
OpenResearch plans to publish additional findings in the coming months on the cash transfers' impact on housing outcomes, political attitudes and the recipients' children.
The push for guaranteed basic income
There are different visions for basic income, with some pushing for payments targeting certain demographics while others have called for a broader universal basic income that would transfer money to every American adult.
How it's going:Guaranteed basic income pilot programs are growing around the country
In a 2016 blog post, OpenAI CEO Sam Altman said the idea of a basic income study had “intrigued” him, and he wanted to study the concept in anticipation of technology eliminating jobs.
“I think that, combined with innovation driving down the cost of having a great life, by doing something like this we could eventually make real progress towards eliminating poverty,” Altman’s post read.
Other big names in Silicon Valley – including former Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey and Tesla CEO Elon Musk – have advocated for guaranteed basic income over the years, and dozens of pilot programs have launched across the country as researchers work to figure out when and how these programs are most effective.
Research so far shows basic income can help lower-income families afford the basics. One 2020 study from Columbia University’s Center on Poverty and Social Policy found $250 a month for adults and children can reduce poverty by 40%. Another 2020 report from the Stanford Basic Income Lab said overall evidence “consistently demonstrates that unconditional cash in low- and middle-income countries leads to a measurable decrease in poverty.”
But the concept has received pushback.
More than half of U.S. adults opposed a universal basic income of about $1,000 a month for adults when surveyed by Pew Research Center in 2020, and the greatest opposition was among white adults. A number of states, including Iowa and South Dakota, have passed bills that prohibit counties or cities from providing guaranteed income programs as skeptics argued that the money would discourage people from working.
Basic income studies have shown mixed results on its influence on employment, according to Sara Kimberlin, executive director and senior research scholar at the Stanford Center on Poverty and Inequality. Sometimes recipients have higher employment rates than the control group. Other studies show a decrease in employment, although Kimberlin notes that can be for positive reasons, like cutting back work hours to take care of children and other family members.
"There really isn't anywhere in the United States where someone can live on just $1,000 a month," Kimberlin said. "So of course people are working, and they have income from other sources, and they have needs that go beyond what can be covered with $1,000 a month."
veryGood! (234)
Related
- 2 killed, 3 injured in shooting at makeshift club in Houston
- Police seek suspects caught on video after fireworks ignite California blaze
- Russia and China push back against U.S. warnings over military and economic forays in the melting Arctic
- What is Crowdstrike? What to know about company linked to global IT outage
- See you latte: Starbucks plans to cut 30% of its menu
- What's a capo? Taylor Swift asks for one during her acoustic set in Hamburg
- Find Out Which America's Sweethearts: Dallas Cowboys Cheerleaders Stars Made the 2024 Squad
- Netanyahu is in Washington at a fraught time for Israel and the US. What to know about his visit
- 'Squid Game' without subtitles? Duolingo, Netflix encourage fans to learn Korean
- New Jersey Sen. Bob Menendez set to resign on Aug. 20 after being convicted on federal bribery charges
Ranking
- B.A. Parker is learning the banjo
- Steve Bannon’s trial in border wall fundraising case set for December, after his ongoing prison term
- New York’s Marshes Plagued by Sewage Runoff and Lack of Sediment
- Voters who want Cornel West on presidential ballot sue North Carolina election board
- Rylee Arnold Shares a Long
- Democratic delegates cite new energy while rallying behind Kamala Harris for president
- Illinois woman sentenced to 2 years in prison for sending military equipment to Russia
- Former US Army civilian employee sentenced to 15 years for stealing nearly $109 million
Recommendation
Backstage at New York's Jingle Ball with Jimmy Fallon, 'Queer Eye' and Meghan Trainor
'Horrifying': Officials, lawmakers, Biden react to deputy shooting Sonya Massey
Chet Hanks says he's slayed the ‘monster’: ‘I'm very much at peace’
SCS Token Giving Wings to the CyberFusion Trading System
FACT FOCUS: Inspector general’s Jan. 6 report misrepresented as proof of FBI setup
All the Surprising Rules Put in Place for the 2024 Olympics
Fans drop everything, meet Taylor Swift in pouring rain at Hamburg Eras Tour show
Bangladesh protests death toll nears 180, with more than 2,500 people arrested after days of unrest